A new study suggests that behavioural barriers are slowing the adoption of Integrated Pest Management (IPM) strategies.
Researchers from the University of Liverpool and the University of Warwick say current policy under the UK Pesticides National Action Plan 2025 may not be enough to meet pesticide reduction targets by 2030 without greater emphasis on training, knowledge sharing and practical support for farmers.
The research combined mathematical modelling of crop disease spread with behavioural analysis of farmer decision-making to explore why uptake of IPM remains low despite its potential benefits.
Focusing on septoria control in winter wheat, the team compared conventional pesticide-based approaches with IPM under different policy scenarios to explore the potential outcomes of different methods of incentivising IPM adoption. These scenarios included the introduction of a per-hectare subsidy for IPM use; investment in research and technology that increases the effectiveness of IPM; and investment in improving grower access to knowledge and resources about IPM implementation.
The results suggest that IPM uptake is likely to remain very low, reaching around 2% by 2030. This is well below the level needed to meet national pesticide reduction targets, which assume a 10% reduction in fungicide users compared with 2018 levels.
The study found that financial incentives alone are unlikely to drive widespread adoption. Growers’ responsiveness to the potential profitability of IPM was damped by other barriers to its adoption. Addressing these constraints was found to be the key factor in influencing decision making. This aligns with the findings of previous surveys where growers have self-reported the main barriers to IPM adoption as including a lack of familiarity with and confidence in IPM, and the high time and effort requirements in gaining access to knowledge and resources about IPM adoption.
Researchers also found that encouraging earlier adoption could improve the likelihood of meeting long-term targets, as early increases in uptake can have lasting effects over time.
The authors say policy should go further than financial incentives and place greater emphasis on practical training, improved understanding of IPM, and better access to advisory support.
Dr Edward Hill, a data scientist at the University of Liverpool, said: “Meeting national environmental targets is as much a social challenge as it is a scientific one. By combining epidemiological data with behavioural insights, this work highlights the need to improve how crop growers are supported with the knowledge they need to implement IPM effectively in practice.”
Dr Stephen Parnell, plant disease epidemiologist at the University of Warwick, added: “Technological and financial solutions alone are not enough. Greater adoption of IPM will depend on improving grower knowledge, reducing the risks associated with changing practice, and strengthening access to training and advisory support within real farming systems.”